More bogus supplements for health

avatar

I am not a fan of the supplement industry in a general sense. This industry is a multi-billion dollar a year industry and it mostly preys on people's ignorance or because people want to be sold a miracle in a jar. Some of my own family members have fallen victim to many of these passing fads and it is kind of tragic because if they do feel anything from taking most supplements it is simply a placebo effect.

Many of these products make dubious claims such as being something that can aid in the prevention of cancer or they will make some vague claim that it contributes to bone strength, bone density, yada yada yada. The claim is really not that important but merely that the studies that they will reference are nearly always funded by the people who are selling the product, which is always something you should be leery of but remarkably the manufacturers are able to get away with this in the supplement industry probably because they are a powerful lobbying group.


image.png
src

It can be a bit alarming when you go into a Vitamin Shoppe or some store like GNC because there are just so many products all of which are making grandiose claims about what the product actually does. Now in rare instances there have been studies conducted where something like fish oil or St. John's Wort do actually do something that benefits the body, but in order for this to end up being the case an extremely specific dosage combined with other factors such as diet needed to exist in order to achieve such ends and even then, the results tend to be extremely minor to the point where it can only be detected with some very sophisticated blood tests. Basically, the opportunity for you to achieve similar results in your kitchen is going to be slim to none.

It can be very difficult to get the exact right dosage of these herbs in a capsule and this is made a lot more difficult when the manufacturers of the product themselves don't even bother putting whatever the herb they are meant to be selling you in the actual pills.

It wasn't that long ago that a massive recall of supplements happened in multiple US states when some Attorney Generals joined forces to test a bunch of supplements that were commonly sold at Walgreens, GNC and Wal-Mart, among other outlets.

They went after popular supplements initially such as St John's Wort, Gingo Biloba, and Echinacea. When they conducted tests to see if the percentages indicated on the packaging were correct I think they expected them to not be accurate, what they and the public likely weren't expecting to discover was that a great percentage of the products didn't contain ANY of these herbs at all. According to then Attorney General Matty Mack, “In a good number of cases, there was no organic material in the product.” That's right folks, in many of these pills they found that they contained nothing but filler and in some instances they had the gall to simply package sand in a capsule and then sell it on to the public.

In 80% of the overall tests, the capsules did NOT contain what it said on the labels.

The industry paid a bunch of class action fees, recalled the products while making some sort of excuse, and then did as much as they could in order to bury the story. I would imagine that many people never even knew that this happened even though it wasn't that long ago. You can see the official report here just in case you think I am making this information up. I am not.

The thing that gets me is that even if the bottles DID contain what was written on the labels, which they didn't, their claims of health benefits are spurious at best and intentional lies at worst.

I am not a big believer in alternative medicine and there was a comedian whose name eludes me who once quipped "I don't believe in alternative medicine because if a product is called "alternative medicine" it is because it either has not been proven to do what it claims or it has been proven that it does NOT do that. Do you know what alternative medicine is called when it does work? It's called medicine."

Don't fall for the hype folks. If a product sounds too good to be true there is a fantastic chance that this is because it isn't true. The only supplements I believe in are whey protein and maybe creatine. These two products have been proven time and time again by independent research and testing to do what it says on the tin. Now we just have to be apprehensive about even these products actually containing what it says on the label as well. If you have the opportunity, getting your protein from a natural source such as real food is always the better option. If not, use a well known brand that has been independently tested to contain what it says on the label.


combo fatty.jpg
from elite athlete, to fat ass, to the strongest I have ever been in my life over the course of 20 years. I didn't go to school to know what I know but mostly I learned what I know from doing things incorrectly at first. Maybe you can learn from my mistakes as well



0
0
0.000
9 comments
avatar

I buy vitamins but only from reputable companies. I buy vitamin d as coming from the UK you don't get a lot of sun. A lot of vitamins are filled with bad fillers, so I shop carefully.

0
0
0.000
avatar

What is worrying we know it is not what the packaging says and very few countries actually check up on this. These supplements are not cheap yet we know they would cost very little to make and why so many unscrupulous companies are involved in this sector. I knew someone who had a supplements company and he was seriously wealthy.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Herbalife is a big example: Virtually no regulation of any sort and they make billions every year. They are so huge that they sponsor major sport teams and this adds credibility to their nonsense. It's just one of those things that if people bothered to look beyond the advertising that they would realize they are buying snake oil.

0
0
0.000
avatar

A perfect example and what a great business if you are the owner.

0
0
0.000
avatar

The snake oil business is still alive an well. I would hope they are not using some stuff that was previously sold as cure-alls, but was often poisonous. I tend to put my trust in science. If something actually does you good then I'm sure it will have been studied. Anecdote is not evidence. I know the big medical companies try to corner the market, but they can't suppress all studies.

Stay well.

!BEER

0
0
0.000
avatar

There are some good companies out there, but they are so difficult to identify from the garbage. Take whey protein for example: There are hundreds of manufacturers of this product which in my mind is a good product. However, probably half of them do not contain what it says on the package. Whenever you see "***" next to any sort of level of percentage on a container, it is almost certainly a lie.

0
0
0.000